Beginning Auto Layout Tutorial in iOS 7: Part 2

Matthijs Hollemans

iOS 7 Feast

Note from Ray: Tutorial Team member Matthijs Hollemans (the iOS Apprentice Series author) has ported this tutorial to iOS 7 as part of the iOS 7 feast. We hope you enjoy!

In part 1 of this Auto Layout tutorial you saw that the old “struts-and-springs” model for making user interfaces cannot easily solve all layout problems. Auto Layout is the solution, but because this technology is so powerful it is also a bit more tricky to use.

Thankfully, Xcode 5 makes Auto Layout a lot easier. If you tried Auto Layout in Xcode 4 and gave up, then we invite you to give it another try with Xcode 5.

In this second part and final part of the Auto Layout tutorial series, you’ll continue learning all about constraints and how to apply them!

A little runtime excursion

This Auto Layout tutorial begins with a very simple app that looks like this:
The starter app

It has two buttons that have their background color set just so it’s clearer to see their boundaries. The buttons have a number of constraints between them. If you’ve been following along with the previous part you can continue using your existing app. Simply remove the other two buttons from the canvas.

If you’re starting from scratch, create a new iPhone application using the Single View Application template. Drag two buttons into the scene and give them a background color. Use the Editor\Pin menu to make a Vertical Spacing constraint between the two buttons (40 points), and a Bottom Space to Superview constraint on the lower button (20 points). Use the Editor\Align menu to center the yellow button horizontally in the container, and again to align the left edges of both buttons.

Playing with this in Interface Builder is all well and good, but let’s see how this works at runtime. Add the following method to ViewController.m:

- (IBAction)buttonTapped:(UIButton *)sender
{
    if ([[sender titleForState:UIControlStateNormal] isEqualToString:@"X"]) {
        [sender setTitle:@"A very long title for this button" 
                forState:UIControlStateNormal];
   } else {
        [sender setTitle:@"X" forState:UIControlStateNormal];
   }
}

This toggles between a long title and a short title for the button that triggered the event. Connect this action method to both of the buttons in Interface Builder. Ctrl-drag from each button to the view controller and select buttonTapped: in the popup.

Run the app and tap the buttons to see how it behaves. Perform the test in both portrait and landscape orientations.

Short and long titles

Regardless of which button has the long title and which has the short title, the layout always satisfies the constraints you have given it:

  • The lower button is always center-aligned in the window, horizontally.
  • The lower button always sits 20 points from the bottom of the window.
  • The top button is always left-aligned with the lower button and 40 points above it.

That is the entire specification for your user interface.

For fun, remove the Leading Alignment constraint (select it in the outline pane and press Delete on your keyboard), then select both buttons in Interface Builder and from the Align menu pick Right Edges. Now run the app again and notice the differences.

Repeat, but now choose Align\Horizontal Centers. That will always center the top button with respect to the bottom button. Run the app and see how the buttons act when you tap them. (Remember, if you get a dashed orange box when you change the constraints, you can use the Editor\Resolve Auto Layout Issues menu to update the button frames accordingly.)

Fixing the width

The Pin menu has an option for Widths Equally. If you set this constraint on two views, then Auto Layout will always make both views equally wide, based on which one is the largest. Let’s play with that for a minute.

Select both buttons and choose Editor\Pin\Widths Equally. This adds a new constraint to both buttons:

Buttons with the Equal Widths constraint

You have seen this type of constraint before, in the first part of this tutorial. It looks like the usual T-bar but in the middle it has a circle with an equals sign.

Even though there are two T-bars, in the Document Outline this shows up as a single Equal Widths constraint:

Equal Widths constraint in document outline

Changing the label text on one button will now change the size of the other one as well. Change the bottom button’s label to “X”, just to make it really small. You will notice that the top button no longer fits its text:

Top button text no longer fits

So how does Auto Layout know which button’s size to use for both of them? If you pay close attention, you’ll see that the top button’s frame is no longer correct:

Top button misplaced frame

Obviously this is not what you want, so select the top button and choose Size to Fit Content from the Editor menu (or press ⌘ =). Now the text fits inside the button again – or rather, the button fits around the text – and due to the Equal Widths constraint the yellow button also resizes.

Run the app and tap the buttons. The buttons always have the same width, regardless of which one has the largest label:

Equal widths buttons in app

Of course, when both labels are very short, both buttons will shrink equally. After all, unless there is a constraint that prevents it, buttons will size themselves to fit their content exactly, no more, no less. What was that called again? Right, the intrinsic content size.

Intrinsic Content Size

Before Auto Layout, you always had to tell buttons and other controls how big they should be, either by setting their frame or bounds properties or by resizing them in Interface Builder. But it turns out that most controls are perfectly capable of determining how much space they need, based on their content.

A label knows how wide and tall it is because it knows the length of the text that has been set on it, as well as the font size for that text. Likewise for a button, which might combine the text with a background image and some padding.

The same is true for segmented controls, progress bars, and most other controls, although some may only have a predetermined height but an unknown width.

This is known as the intrinsic content size, and it is an important concept in Auto Layout. You have already seen it in action with the buttons. Auto Layout asks your controls how big they need to be and lays out the screen based on that information.

Usually you want to use the intrinsic content size, but there are some cases where you may not want to do that. You can prevent this by setting an explicit Width or Height constraint on a control.

Imagine what happens when you set an image on a UIImageView if that image is much larger than the screen. You usually want to give image views a fixed width and height and scale the content, unless you want the view to resize to the dimensions of the image.

So what happens when one of the buttons has a fixed Width constraint on it? Buttons calculate their own size, but you can override this by giving them a fixed width. Select the top button and choose Pin\Width from the menu. This adds a solid T-bar below the button:

Button with Fixed Width constraint

Because this sort of constraint only applies to the button itself, not to its superview, it is listed in the Document Outline below the button object. In this case, you have fixed the button to a width of 46 points.

You cannot simply drag the button’s resize handles to make the button wider. If you do, you’ll end up with a whole bunch of orange boxes. Remember that Xcode 5 does not automatically update the constraints for you (unlike Xcode 4). So if you make a change to the button’s frame, it’s up to you to make the constraints match again. The alternative approach is to simply change the constraint instead.

Select the Width constraint and go to the Attributes inspector. Change Constant to 80 to make the button wider:

Width constraint attributes

Run the app and tap the buttons. What happens? The button text does change, but it gets truncated because there is not enough room:

Button text clipped

Because the top button has a fixed-width constraint and both buttons are required to be the same size, they will never shrink or grow.

Note: You probably wouldn’t set a Width constraint on a button by design – it is best to let the button use its intrinsic size – but if you ever run into a layout problem where you expect your controls to change size and they don’t, then double check to make sure a fixed Width constraint didn’t sneak in there.

Play around with this stuff for a bit to get the hang of pinning and aligning views. Get a feel for it, because not everything is immediately obvious. Just remember that there must always be enough constraints so that Auto Layout can determine the position and size for all views.

Got enough constraints

Gallery example

You should now have an idea of what constraints are and how you can build up your layouts by forging relationships between the different views. In the following sections, you will see how to use Auto Layout and constraints to create layouts that meet real-world scenarios.

Let’s pretend you want to make an app that has a gallery of your favorite programmers. It looks like this in portrait and landscape:

The Gallery app

The screen is divided into four equal quarters. Each quarter has an image view and a label. How would you approach this?

Let’s start by setting up the basic app. Create a new iPhone project using the Single View Application template and name it “Gallery”.

Open Main.storyboard. From the Object Library, drag a plain View object onto the canvas. Resize the view so that it is 160 by 284 points, and change its background color to be something other than white (for example, green):

Green view in canvas

Note: There are two main reasons why you would drop a plain UIView onto a storyboard: a) You’re going to use it as a container for other views, which helps with organizing the content of your scenes; or b) It is a placeholder for a custom view or control, and you will also set its Class attribute to the name of your own UIView or UIControl subclass.

Let’s give this view some constraints. You’ve already seen two ways to make constraints: the Editor\Pin and Align menus, and Ctrl-dragging between views. There is a third method that you’ll use here. At the bottom of the Interface Builder window is a row of buttons:

Auto Layout buttons

The four circled buttons are for Auto Layout. From left to right they are: Align, Pin, Resolve Auto Layout Issues, and Resizing Behavior. The first three perform the same functions as the corresponding items from the Editor menu. The Resizing Behavior button allows you to change what happens to the constraints when you resize views.

Select the green view and click the Pin button. A popup appears that lets you add a variety of constraints:

The pin popup

The Spacing to nearest neighbor section at the top is what you’ll use most often. Click the four T-bar thingies so they become solid red:

Spacing to nearest neighbor

This will create four new constraints between the green view and its superview, one for each side of the view. The actual spacing values may be different for you, depending on where you placed the view. (You don’t have the change these values to match mine). Click Add 4 Constraints to finish.

Your storyboard should now look something like this:

View with the four new constraints

This view needs four constraints to keep it in place. Unlike a button or label, a plain UIView does not have an intrinsic content size. There must always be enough constraints to determine the position and size of each view, so this view also needs constraints to tell it what size it needs to be.

You may wonder, where are these size constraints? In this case, the size of the view is implied by the size of the superview. The constraints in this layout are two Horizontal Spaces and two Vertical Spaces, and these all have fixed lengths. You can see this in the Document Outline:

Constraints for green view in document outline

The width of the green view is calculated by the formula “width of superview minus (98 + 62)” and its height by the formula “height of superview minus (65 + 199)”. The space constraints are fixed, so the view has no choice but to resize. (Again, your values may be different depending on where you put the view.)

When you rotate the app, the dimensions of the superview change from 320×568 to 568×320. Plug this new width and height into these formulas, and you’ll get the new size of the green view (408×56).

You can see this for yourself when you run the app and flip to landscape, but you can also simulate it directly in Interface Builder. Open the Assistant editor (press the button in Xcode’s toolbar that looks like a butler/alien) and select Preview in the jump bar:

Storyboard preview

Click the arrow button at the bottom to change the orientation to landscape. This gives you an instant preview of what the storyboard’s layout will look like in landscape orientation. The green view has resized in order to satisfy its Horizontal and Vertical Space constraints.

You can leave this preview pane open as you design your UI and it will update automatically. You can also use it to toggle between the 3.5 and 4-inch form factors.

Note: Maybe you wondered why the constraint at the top of the view didn’t go all the way up to the top of the screen:

Space at top

Instead it stops at the status bar. But in iOS 7 the status bar is always drawn on top of the view controller — it is no longer a separate bar — so what gives? When you created the constraint it didn’t actually attach to the top of the screen but to an invisible line called the Top Layout Guide.

On a regular view controller this guide sits at 20 points from the top of the screen, at least when the status bar is not hidden. In a navigation controller it sits below the navigation bar. Because the navigation bar has a different height in landscape, the Top Layout Guide moves with the bar when the device is rotated. That makes it easy to place views relative to the navigation bar. There is also a Bottom Layout Guide that is used for the tab bar and toolbars.

You may not always want your UIView to resize when the device rotates, so you can use constraints to give the view a fixed width and/or height. Let’s do that now. Select the green view and click the Pin button; in the popup put checkmarks in front of Width and Height.

Pin popup with width and height selected

Click Add 2 Constraints to finish. You have now added two new constraints to the view, a 160 point Width constraint and a 284 point Height constraint:

Width and height constraints on green view

Because Width and Height apply to just this view, they are located in the Document Outline under the View itself. Usually, constraints express a relationship between two different views – for example, the Horizontal and Vertical Space constraints are between the green view and its superview – but you can consider the Width and Height constraints to be a relationship between the green view and itself.

Run the app. Yup, looks good in portrait. Now flip over to landscape. Whoops! Not only does it not look like you wanted – the view has changed size again – but the Xcode debug pane has dumped a nasty error message:

Gallery[39367:a0b] Unable to simultaneously satisfy constraints.
	Probably at least one of the constraints in the following list is one you don't want. Try this: (1) look at each constraint and try to figure out which you don't expect; (2) find the code that added the unwanted constraint or constraints and fix it. (Note: If you're seeing NSAutoresizingMaskLayoutConstraints that you don't understand, refer to the documentation for the UIView property translatesAutoresizingMaskIntoConstraints) 
(
    "<NSLayoutConstraint:0xc1a1e80 V:[UIView:0xc1a2b10(284)]>",
    "<NSLayoutConstraint:0xc1a36c0 V:[_UILayoutGuide:0xc1a2d20]-(65)-[UIView:0xc1a2b10]>",
    "<NSLayoutConstraint:0xc1a36f0 V:[UIView:0xc1a2b10]-(199)-[_UILayoutGuide:0xc1a3230]>",
    "<_UILayoutSupportConstraint:0xc15dbd0 V:[_UILayoutGuide:0xc1a2d20(20)]>",
    "<_UILayoutSupportConstraint:0xc1a1510 V:|-(0)-[_UILayoutGuide:0xc1a2d20]   (Names: '|':UIView:0xc1a2930 )>",
    "<_UILayoutSupportConstraint:0xc1a3720 V:[_UILayoutGuide:0xc1a3230(0)]>",
    "<_UILayoutSupportConstraint:0xc1a30e0 _UILayoutGuide:0xc1a3230.bottom == UIView:0xc1a2930.bottom>",
    "<NSAutoresizingMaskLayoutConstraint:0x8c6c6a0 h=--& v=--& H:[UIView:0xc1a2930(320)]>"
)
 
Will attempt to recover by breaking constraint 
<NSLayoutConstraint:0xc1a1e80 V:[UIView:0xc1a2b10(284)]>
 
Break on objc_exception_throw to catch this in the debugger.
The methods in the UIConstraintBasedLayoutDebugging category on UIView listed in <UIKit/UIView.h> may also be helpful.
 
. . .

Remember when I said that there must be enough constraints so that Auto Layout can calculate the positions and sizes of all the views? Well, this is an example where there are too many constraints. Whenever you get the error “Unable to simultaneously satisfy constraints”, it means that your constraints are conflicting somewhere.

Let’s look at those constraints again:

Conflicting constraints

There are six constraints set on the green view, the four Spacing constraints you saw earlier (1-4) and the new Width and Height constraints that you have just set on it (5 and 6). So where is the conflict?

In portrait mode there shouldn’t be a problem because the math adds up. The width of the superview is 320 points. If you add the lengths of the Horizontal Space and Width constraints, then you should also end up at 320. The way I have positioned the view, that is: 98 + 160 + 62 = 320 indeed. Likewise, the vertical constraints should add up to 568.

But when you rotate the device to landscape, the window (and therefore the superview) is 568 points wide. That means 98 + 160 + 62 + ? = 568. There are 248 extra points that need to go somewhere in that equation and Auto Layout doesn’t know where to get them from. Likewise for the vertical axis.

The conflict here is that either the width of the view is fixed and one of the margins must be flexible, or the margins are fixed and the width must be flexible. You can’t have both. So one of these constraints has to go. In the above example, you want the view to have the same width in both portrait and landscape, so the trailing Horizontal Space has got to go.

Remove the Horizontal Space at the right and the Vertical Space at the bottom. The storyboard should look like this:

Conflicting constraints fixed

Now the view has just the right number of constraints to determine its size and position — no more, no less. Run the app and verify that the error message is gone and that the view stays the same size after rotating.

Note: Even though Interface Builder does its best to warn you about invalid layouts, it cannot perform miracles. It will warn you when there are too few constraints but it doesn’t fare so well at detecting layouts with too many constraints. At least Auto Layout spits out a detailed error message when something is wrong. You will learn more about analyzing these error messages and diagnosing layout problems in “Intermediate Auto Layout” in iOS 6 by Tutorials.

Painting the portraits

Drag a Label onto the green view. Notice that now the guides appear within that green view, because it will be the superview for the label.

Dragging the label

Position the label against the bottom margin, horizontally centered against the guides. Add a space constraint to anchor the label against the bottom of the green view, at 20 points distance. The quickest way is to use the Pin button and just select the T-bar at the bottom:

Pin menu with bottom T-bar selected

Now add a constraint to center the label horizontally. You’ve seen how to do this with the Editor\Align menu but you can also use the Align button from the floating Auto Layout menu. Select the label and click the Align button to bring up the popup:

Align horizontal center

Put a checkbox in front of Horizontal Center in Container and then click Add 1 Constraint. The storyboard should now look like this:

Label constraints

Notice that these two new Horizontal and Vertical Space constraints are listed under the green view’s own Constraints section, not in the main view.

Drag a new Image View object onto the storyboard, and make the layout look like this:

Image view with constraints

The image view is pinned to the top, left, and right edges of its superview, but its bottom is connected to the top of the label with a standard spacing of 8 points. If you’re unsure of how to do this, then follow these steps.

1. Drag the image view into the green view but don’t worry too much about its size or position:

After adding the image view

2. With the image view selected, press the Pin button and choose the following options:

Pin menu for image view

The top, left, and right T-bars are set to 20 points but the bottom one is set to 8 points. Important: For Update Frames you should choose Items of New Constraints. If you had left this to the default of None, the storyboard would look something like this:

Misplaced image view

The constraints you chose result in a different frame than the image view’s current position and size. But if you choose Items of New Constraints, Interface Builder will automatically adjust the frame as it adds the constraints and everything looks dandy:

Image view frame OK

Of course, if you do end up with a misplaced frame, you can use the Resolve Auto Layout Issues button to fix it:

Resolve issues menu

Download the resources for this tutorial and unzip the file. You will find an Images folder – add this folder into your project. Set Ray.png as the image for the image view, change the image view’s mode to Aspect Fit and set its background color to white. Change the label’s text to say “Ray”.

Your layout should now look like this:

Gallery with Ray

Notice that the constraints inside the green view turned to orange. This happened the moment you set the image on the image view. How come your layout is suddenly invalid? Fortunately you can take the guesswork out of it and let Xcode tell you exactly what’s wrong.

Click the small red arrow next to View Controller Scene in the Document Outline to view the issues:

Content priority ambiguity error

You have a Content Priority Ambiguity error. That’s quite the mouthful. This is what it means: If neither the image view nor the label has a fixed height, then Auto Layout doesn’t know by how much to scale each if the height of the green view should change. (Interface Builder seems to ignore for now that the green view actually has a fixed Height constraint set on it.)

Let’s say at some point in your app the green view becomes 100 points taller. How should Auto Layout distribute these new 100 points among the label and the image view? Does the image view become 100 points taller while the label stays the same size? Or does the label become taller while the image view stays the same? Do they both get 50 points extra, or is it split 25/75, 40/60, or in some other possible combination?

If you don’t solve this problem somehow then Auto Layout is going to have to guess and the results may be unpredictable.

The proper solution is to change the “Content Compression Resistance Priority” of the label. You will learn more about that later on. For now, go into the Size inspector for the label and set the vertical Content Compression Resistance Priority to 751. That makes it one higher than the priority of the image view. While you’re at it, set Content Hugging Priority to 252.

Compression resistance priority

The T-bars should turn blue again and the Auto Layout warnings are gone.

Adding the other heads

Drag the green view into the main view’s top-left corner. Recall that the green view had Horizontal Space and Vertical Space constraints that determined its position in the parent view. It still has those and they cause the frame of the view to be misaligned.

Misaligned green view

To fix this, use the Resolve Auto Layout Issues button and choose Update Constraints. Previously you used Update Frames, which moved and resized the view the match the constraints. Here you want to do the opposite: you want the constraints to update to match the frame.

Note that the Vertical Space at the top is now negative. That happens because this constraint is connected to the Top Layout Guide. But there’s no reason why constraints cannot have negative values, so you can leave this as is. (If it bothers you, delete that “Vertical Space (-20)” constraint and pin the view to the top of the window.)

The Horizontal Space now has size 0 and is represented by a thick blue line at the left edge of the window. So even though the view sits completely in the corner, it still needs constraints to anchor it there:

View in top-left corner

Select the green view and tap ⌘D to duplicate it. Move the duplicate into the top-right corner:

Duplicate view in top-right corner

Notice that the T-bars are orange. When you made the duplicate, it apparently lost its constraints for the X and Y position. To fix that, pin the view to the top and the right edges of the window.

Duplicate two more times and put these copies in the bottom-left and bottom-right corners, respectively. Again, pin these views to their corners.

Change the screen design to the following:

Gallery with all 4 heads

Those are some good-looking programmers! :-)

Run the app. It looks good in portrait, but not so much in landscape:

Gallery landscape bad

It should be pretty obvious what went wrong: you’ve set a fixed width and height on the four brightly-colored container views, so they will always have those sizes, regardless of the size of their superview.

Select the Width (160) and Height (284) constraints from all four views and delete them (this is easiest in the Document Outline). If you run the app now, you’ll get something like this:

Still bad in landscape

Note: If you’re wondering why some of the views are larger than others, this is again related to the intrinsic content size. The size of the image determines how large the image view is; the size of the text determines how large the label is. Taken together with the constraints for the margins — 20 points on all sides — this determines the total size of each view.

This looks very much like the problem you solved in the introduction in part 1, so if you think back to how you solved that, you’ll recall that you gave the views equal widths and heights.

Select all four colored views. This is easiest in the Document Outline; hold and click on the four views. You can add the constraints in one go. In the Pin popup put checkmarks in front of Equal Widths and Equal Heights and then press Add 6 Constraints.

Add equal widths and heights constraints

Run the app again and rotate the device. Hmm… still no good:

Gallery landscape equal sizes

All the views do have the same height, and they also appear to have the same width, so your constraints are being met. It’s just not the width and height that you want them to have.

Just saying that all four views must have equal sizes is not enough to determine what those sizes should actually be, because Auto Layout does not know how these four views are connected to each other. They appear side-by-side in the design, but there are no actual constraints between them. Auto Layout does not know that it needs to split the window width between the “Ray” and “Matthijs” boxes.

If Auto Layout can’t figure this out by itself, you have to tell it.

To be related

Select the Ray and Matthijs boxes and choose Pin\Horizontal Spacing from the Editor menu. Because the boxes are side-by-side, this adds a Horizontal Space constraint with size 0 between them, and that is enough to let Auto Layout know how these two views are related. Also put a Vertical Space between the Ray and Dennis Ritchie boxes using Editor\Pin\Vertical Spacing.

Run the app again, and this time it looks all right:

Gallery landscape OK

Note: Interface Builder still complains about misplaced views at this point. I’m not sure why that happens but it appears to be a bug in Xcode. If these warnings bother you, then select the main view (or the view controller) and from the Resolve Auto Layout Issues menu choose Update All Frames in View Controller. It does not change how the app works at runtime but at least it makes Xcode happy.

A quick note on the image views: they stretch out because you have not given them a fixed size. You may not know it, but that’s intentional on your part. ☺ The image views wouldn’t fit in landscape mode otherwise. However, if you want an image view to keep its original aspect ratio, then you’re out of luck. You cannot achieve the following effect using Interface Builder:

Gallery aspect ratio

Unfortunately, Interface Builder does not currently provide a way to make constraints that keep the aspect ratio of a view intact. To do that, you need to create and set the constraints programmatically. You will learn how to do that in “Intermediate Auto Layout” in iOS 6 by Tutorials.

Where To Go From Here?

If you’ve made it this far, congratulations – you now know what Auto Layout is all about, and have experimented with the basics! But there’s a lot left to learn…

The tutorial you have just read is only the first half of the Beginning Auto Layout chapter from the book iOS 6 by Tutorials. The second half teaches how to use Auto Layout to create more “real-world” screen layouts, and everything else you need to know about using Auto Layout from Interface Builder.

But like any visual design tool, Interface Builder has its limitations and sometimes it just makes more sense to work with the NSLayoutConstraint objects directly from code. iOS 6 by Tutorials dedicates an entire chapter to this topic, Intermediate Auto Layout. So if you want to get to the bottom of Auto Layout, get the book!

Matthijs Hollemans

Matthijs Hollemans is an independent iOS developer and designer who lives to create awesome software. His focus is on iPad apps because he thinks tablets are way cooler than phones. Whenever he is not glued to his screen, Matthijs plays the piano, is into healthy and natural living, and goes out barefoot running. Visit his website at http://www.hollance.com.

Other Items of Interest

raywenderlich.com Weekly

Sign up to receive the latest tutorials from raywenderlich.com each week, and receive a free epic-length tutorial as a bonus!

Advertise with Us!

Come check out Alt U

Our Books

Our Team

Video Team

... 9 total!

Swift Team

... 15 total!

iOS Team

... 47 total!

Android Team

... 15 total!

OS X Team

... 12 total!

Apple Game Frameworks Team

... 15 total!

Unity Team

... 11 total!

Articles Team

... 8 total!